Sashi, being the sweetheart he is, conned me into this extremely rushed piece with praise and flattery. I was hooked, as you can see. It’s not the best thing I’ve ever written, and bear in mind this was done very quickly, so excuse me if I don’t meet certain QC standards. Here goes:
Color Blind.
I’ve been blogging since 1999. For me, that’s a long time. Since I started, until present, when I do post about issues concerning Malaysia, I’ve always managed to whine, complain and sometimes rant about the worrying state the country seems to always be in.
This has garnered a considerable amount of comments from Malaysians and foreigners, both online and in ‘real life.’ The Malaysians usually, either tell me I’m crazy to still be living here, or like some of the kindred spirits I’ve met through blogging, tell me how we should keep trying to make a difference and push some sort of change, however small, forward.
The one question that has always stuck in my mind however, was when one Malaysian commenter, asked me (after the Sepet/Gubra- Pencemar Budaya debacle):
“Why do you love Malaysia, and why do you bother staying?”
To be quite honest, until today, until now, this very second typing up this post, I don’t know. I have thought about it, when I am happy, I have thought about it when I am sad. I have seen friends and family beaten by the system, I have seen innocents persecuted (Nathaniel Tan’s recent detention, the demolition of Kampung Berembang etc.), and I have seen the powers that be divide and conquer us ala penjajah, many, many times. In fact, some sins that I have forgiven, often come to haunt me when I think of the answers to this question.
Growing up in a largely Malay part of suburbia in Ampang, I went to public school just like everyone else. I received a mediocre education, like much of the students of the world. Education is a business, just like anything else. And sometimes when the demand is too high, the quality gets affected. Nevertheless, I learned what I had to. School was a painful time for me. Suffering from depression at age 14 to 17, life was bleak and the people and insults I faced were tough. We all know, kids are cruel. In Buffalo, New York or in Pandan Indah, Ampang.
Everyday, while I was in Form Two, there was this one boy, I remember his name. But, just in case he reads this, I won’t state it here. He was in my class, and tormented me every single day, about my color, my race, my hair, my clothes, my weight, my height. And yes, he was Malay. Coming from a pretty liberal family, I was never thought about race or religion, except my own and the guidelines to follow, so this was very much a harsh awakening for me. I used to write angry, vicious journals entries about how I would kick his ass if I could, and once after particularly cruel comment, I think I wrote about spitting on him. Of all the personal insults he threw at me, the one that hurt the most were the ones where he called me ‘keling.’
I can safely and proudly say, I never retaliated with a derogatory racial term, although, I really wanted to- in my heart of hearts. I wanted to believe in the things I heard said around me- the stereotypes of lazy, ungrateful Malays, stingy and cheating Chinese and naturally, educated, eloquent, albeit alcoholic Indians who beat the shit out of their wives.
My mother a product of the government employment system, suffered for promotions, worked hard and had her efforts shunned many times, by people who knew what they were doing. But, when you work in a collective, where the approval of the majority matters, you tend to get sidelined. The idea that, she, a single mother would have to break her back working because my family, Indian and middle class didn’t qualify for government help, killed me.
It didn’t help that as I grew up, my rage and my frustrations vanished against most of these racists, but the people around me continued to call me a silly idealist, someone who was in a different reality, one where color didn’t matter. To me, that was and still is, how I view the world. But my friends and family have often called me stupid for being color blind. Perhaps, in a country like ours, it is sometimes stupid.
I don’t know anymore.
I do know that, I love this country- tanah tumpah darahku. I love its people, I love its food, I love its diversity and I love the common thread of Malaysian-ness that unites us all. Yes, the one we sometimes forget in our haste to move forward. I see our flaws as well, and as much as I hate the political drama and injustices, Malaysia is a friend, a relative that I can never disown. She keeps putting me down sometimes, and I often hate some of the decisions and statements made on her behalf, but I love her with my very soul. It’s like how they said it in Sepet, it’s a relationship where you love and keeping on loving someone, but sometimes it seems- they never love you back.
It doesn’t matter to me anymore to have my feelings reciprocated. I’ve come to understand that the heart will love what it wants to love, despite all the frustrations and annoyances I’ve faced with Malaysia. This year, and in the years to come, I’m going to keep on loving her. I’m to keep on trying to help. I’m going to keep on hoping. I’m going to keep on keeping on.
I’m here to stay whether she likes it or not.
Happy 50th Birthday Malaysia.
The rest of the series, amazing entries:
50, 49, 48, 47, 46, 45, 44, 43, 42, 41, 40, 39, 38, 37, 36, 35, 34, 33, 32,31, 30, 29, 28, 27, 26, 25, 24, 23, 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, 7 , and me at number 6.
So I’m tagging, Nuraina A Samad.

22 Comments
July 26, 2007 at 12:17 am
Hey Meesh,
Very sentimental piece I must say, Naj sent me a fwd of it. Maybe she was trying to invoke some warm fuzzy pre-merdeka feelings within me, but I guess it didnt work. I won’t get into it, but today at Maybank, I overheard an elderly gentleman say to the officer “Everyone else progressess, and we take a step back, how is that?” (perfect for our 50th anniversary, I snickered to myself)
I know leopards CAN’T change their spots, so I don’t waste time hoping. I use what resources are availble to me here, to enable my children, to have a brighter future, in a country where all citizens are treated equally.
Malaysia doesnt love me, and I couldnt care less. Its just my fate I was born here..better here than Sri Lanka I say ! I have a lot of love saved, of which I will give, to a country I would be proud to call my home.
July 26, 2007 at 2:24 am
michelle,
i think i remember you. i think.
oh, you naughty naughty girl.
now i have to write!
er…do i have a choice here?
kidding…
July 26, 2007 at 2:48 am
Hey Deli,
Thanks for the comment. Different viewpoints always welcome. I would have said I’m sorry to hear you feel this way, but then again, like I said in the post, the heart wants wants the heart wants. So I wish you all the luck in finding a place you can be proud to call home.
July 26, 2007 at 7:06 pm
Yeah, lots of warm fuzzy feelings meesh but sadly i think, it’s misplaced. Malaysia that we know & love is no more. Neither can we change it.It’s fun to day dream , pretend to be idealist but reality is there for us to see. We have a responsibility, to our family, our parents and perhaps in the future our children. We owe it to them to create an enviroment that will nurture them , make them feel safe. Can u feel safe walking alone ,today, now. Do yr parents deserve this fear, do yr children in the future to face such bleakness ?
Have u watched the migrating birds nesting ? they are much smarter then us, most humans. U wont see them nesting in polluted lakes or lakes infested with crocodiles. If there is such danger, they simply move on & nest somehwere where their young can grow safely. It’s about time, we learn from them
July 26, 2007 at 8:38 pm
While I might agree to some degree with Stan and Deli, there is something to be said about the difference between humans and birds.
I guess the level to which the standard of living in Malaysia has deteriorated to a somewhat alarming degree, but manageable enough that leaving or staying is a choice of sorts. But I asked myself yesterday, if Malaysia degraded to the level of, say, Rwanda, and some of us who could leave did, would we leave without looking back for the sakes of our loved ones who couldn’t?
Just a question…
July 26, 2007 at 11:07 pm
I think my issue with all this is not so much about people leaving. I really don’t mind that. I’m not one of those people who are going to be, Oh you traitor. I think just like anything in life, you cut your losses when you can and if you have the means to do so. Human beings are resilient creatures, not unlike birds Stan, it’s true.
In fact, Malaysians who leave have managed to be part of the growing Malaysian diaspora in countries like Australia, UK, the US and other places. Creating a stronghold of Malaysian values, cultures, and traditions. It makes me proud to see my people succeed anywhere, more so in a foreign land.
However, I think this attitude of I’m going to milk Malaysia of what it’s worth, I don’t care about Malaysia or Malaysians, it utter crap. You talk about milking the resources of this country to move elsewhere? Do you understand, can you see how twisted that sounds? I don’t mean to judge, but I’m trying to look at it in a very rational way.
If you’re going to say something like that, you have to be accountable. That is selfish, plain and simple. Besides that, why is there this perception that Malaysia is the government? The bloody BN buffoons and all other stupid, but prevalent individuals- are they Malaysia?
I hardly think so. Malaysia is in you and me. Malaysia is in those that try very hard to make it work, for themselves and the rest of the people here, IRRESPECTIVE of where they are. This perception of Malaysia being the government is rubbish, and stems from apathy we’ve come to rely on. Despite leaving, despite being frustrated with what has been done by these idiots. Malaysia is separate from them I believe.
It is in our loved ones, it is in our families, and it is in our friends. So I echo that question Najah has asked, would you leave if leaving meant leaving MALAYSIA. The Malaysia of the people, the ones we love, fight and live for. Because at the end of the day, my mother is Malaysian, my brother is Malaysian, and my children will be Malaysian someday- and I will fight for them and their rights to be here and to enjoy the fullest life they can. But, that is my decision. If I were ever offered a chance to live elsewhere, I would do it. But, NOT because I don’t want to live here. NOT because I hate my country. But, to see if I could be of better service, learning from others.
I understand this may sounds very saccharine and disgusting to people. But, I’m being honest. For those parents who move away to give your children what you consider better lives, in other countries. Great! Power to you! But, your children will be intrinsically linked to this place because- you carry a piece of this thread with you. Despite all the nation’s failings, we are all bound together by this tapestry. Identifying not with India, or Sri Lanka, or China, or Punjab- but with Malaysia. Whether or not you chose to admit/accept this, you will be passing on bits of this rich thread to your children, and at some point… no matter where they are, they will want to be even a small part of it.
July 27, 2007 at 5:40 am
U are a great idealist and i have to give that to u. Our prespectives are very different. U see from the viewpoint of a single person. I see from someone who is going to get married and hope to hv children 1 day. Having grown up here, i saw how life was and is right now. It’s not about milking resouces. I can proudly state , i hv never milked anyone . I contributed very proudly ,unfortunately not in malaysia, not because i did not wanted to but becuase there was simply not a chance for me. In return for my knowledge & talents, i would hv got a return for my contribution, if i had e chance to contribute. Would that be counted as milking ? of course not , but merely expectation for a reasonable rate of return. Too bad, many of us are denied that. Sometimes birds are still smarter than us, at least they are not idealist, they wont hang around a place full of crocodiles jus becuase their parents laid an egg there.
July 27, 2007 at 7:16 pm
hi meesh,
i’ve done it. and have tagged someone else.
July 28, 2007 at 3:04 am
I love Malaysia. ‘Nuff said.
July 28, 2007 at 4:39 am
Wow Stan. What a lovely end to a proposed rational discussion. How shallow and deluded do you think I am? You think I choose to stay because my parents live here? That’s too bad, I guess.
July 28, 2007 at 8:06 am
No meesh, u are not shallow, deluded yes. It’s no point at this time. Wait perhaps 5 years , Then if we are still around, we will talk about it
July 28, 2007 at 9:11 am
No, it’s alright. I don’t do waiting
July 29, 2007 at 5:53 am
[...] 30, 29, 28, 27, 26, 25, 24, 23, 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, [...]
July 31, 2007 at 10:17 am
Honestly, hats off to meesh for holding on to her ideals, because so few people do so nowadays. We compromise for various reasons, we cut corners here and there, we lose ourselves and then one day, we wake up, family, kids and mortgage in tow, and we realise that we yearn for those days when we had ideals.
I have kids. I have mortgages in two countries, and in some ways, both these countries have a love-hate relationship with me. All I can do is hope that I don’t forget what was important to me before ‘life’ as burden-laden adults likes to call it, hit me. Because those values and ideals, from what I’ve learned from several wise and elderly people, are what’s important at the end of the journey of life, just as it was at the beginning of it.
August 2, 2007 at 5:45 pm
Here is a very interesting article from malaysiakini .
Malaysia aspiring to become an Arab nation
Abang Kontrary
Aug 2, 07 3:45pm Adjust font size:
The majority ethnic group in Singapore are achievement oriented, energetic, pragmatic, ambitious, revere education and respect thrift. Their leaders constantly harp on the need to tighten their belts, and compete harder and smarter. As a consequence, they embrace meritocracy, and have little fear of competition but dread instead closed markets, and uneven playing fields in the arena of international trade.
The majority ethnic group in Malaysia – in spite of their overwhelming domination of the Malaysian judiciary, parliament, police, armed forces, cabinet and civil service – continue to fear the potential achievements of minority ethnic groups, free markets, market discipline, open competition and meritocracy.
Singaporean leaders have no hang-ups about doing whatever it takes to achieve the Southeast Asian edition of ‘The American Dream’ even if it means playing catch-up with high-tech Japan or financial services king Switzerland.
Malaysian leaders, unfortunately, cannot afford to do the same to achieve similar aspirations and hope to stay in power. Sadly for all of us, Malaysian leaders in Umno rest their credibility on upholding and defending supremacist ideologies in order to stay in power under the banner of Ketuanan Melayu (Malay supremacy) or more politely, The Malay Agenda.
They frighten the Malays with bogeymen threats, ruthlessly demonise the Chinese and Indian minorities, and practice grossly discriminatory policies that guarantee unequal racist treatment in education and employment. Sadly again for the rest of us, PAS is equally guilty in terms of regarding Islam in supremacist terms, and would find it near impossible to dialogue with other faiths on equal terms.
We should not therefore compare Malaysian aspirations with Singaporean aspirations. We have chosen different roads to travel. I should therefore like to point out the real road that Malaysians have chosen to travel – that is, the road Malaysian political elites in Umno or PAS must choose to travel if they wish to stay in power.
It is the same road to destruction that rich and corrupt Arab political leaders take to make sure they too stay in power. In very real terms, Malaysia is aspiring to become an Arab-OIC nation in every respect. In terms of what Malaysia is trying to achieve, and as a guide to the future of our country, I shall give My Vision of Malaysia’s 2020.
In the Middle East, there is no democracy. No free press. No free speech. Your safety is not guaranteed. People have been shot dead in Egypt for promoting secularism. Torture is common in Arab jails even before you are convicted. Human rights is not respected. There is no freedom of religion.
Adultery and apostasy is met with stoning and beheadings. Other religious faiths are completely outlawed in Saudi Arabia. There is gross discrimination depending on which religious belief you practice, which tribe or village you come from, and how closely related you are to the ruling elites.
There is slavery and genocide in the Sudan. There is no equal treatment. Even being the ‘wrong type’ of Muslim is dangerous. In Saddam’s Iraq, Kurds were gassed, Shias were sent to the dangerous front-lines, and Sunnis were placed in the elite Republican Guards bringing up the rear. No meritocracy. You get government contracts purely on your standing with the ruling elites in power. No open tender. Best offer does not get the contract. If you are related to the ruling elites by blood, you will get the contract regardless.
There’s no independent judiciary. Right and wrong depends entirely on your standing with the ruling elites in power. No clean politicians. No right to vote. No fair trial. People in power literally get away with murder. Not surprisingly, the work ethic is totally destroyed. Rich Arabs do not place their money in Arab banks but in American and European banks. The moral fibre of the community is completely destroyed, and the sad fact is, Arabs find it very difficult to trust fellow Arabs.
In this type of economic, political and social environment, what would you expect? Of course, people will say we are not yet as bad as many Arab countries that are plagued with low literacy rates, torture, totalitarian rule, gender discrimination, poverty, brutal human rights violations, genocide, racism, religious conflict, slavery, and war. Nevertheless, Malaysia seems intent on catching up.
If we disregard in Malaysia the universal principles of equal treatment, equal citizenship, meritocracy, justice, honesty, independent judiciary, free press, democracy, free speech, freedom of religion, and human rights, and if the Malay Agenda cannot accommodate these ideals, then the writing is surely on the wall.
On this cynically immoral road to destruction that our corrupt and obscenely wealthy Umno leaders have chosen to take to enrich, and entrench themselves in power, I think we as a nation should arrive just in time for Malaysia’s Vision (Umno-PAS-Arab) 2020.
Unless the average Malay voter comes to his senses to see past the racial rhetoric, and see where this country is really headed, then our fates are sealed together as a nation. We are doomed.
August 6, 2007 at 6:44 pm
meesh, lol are you saggitarius? i have a friend who is as idealistic as you and its very endearing. of course, he’s about to get married…so i’m waiting to see what sorta perception/outlook he holds after having kids. that aside, i actually do love all things Malaysian and am usually thrilled when i meet a fellow Malaysian abroad…but when you get back home, it feels like youre a part of The Island (Ewan McGregor & Scarlett Johansson)….now where was that application to migrate again?
August 6, 2007 at 6:46 pm
Actually Deli, I am a Virgo. Which makes my idealism all the more precious. I love it!
August 9, 2007 at 11:01 pm
Ha. I see they got you as well.
You know, I had likened leaving Malaysia to diking out a piece of my heart — not because I love this place, but because it is a part of me.
So when someone asked if this place were to degenerate to Rwanda or worse, my answer would be more or less the same: we’d have gone long ago, soul-damage or not.
Because, come on, mates: this country may not be the best, but it’s not fucking Rwanda, okay?
August 9, 2007 at 11:46 pm
Here’s a thing that struck me. Struck me like a motherfucking slap to the face, man:
“…but the people around me continued to call me a silly idealist, someone who was in a different reality, one where color didn’t matter. To me, that was and still is, how I view the world. But my friends and family have often called me stupid for being color blind. Perhaps, in a country like ours, it is sometimes stupid.”
Maybe. But it’s stupid and important. Because if you cannot dream of a better world, or believe in one, then you might as well take a nice hot bath, slit your wrists, and slip away.
August 10, 2007 at 12:22 am
This is why I love you! You get me! I heart you! It doesn’t matter to me anyway, at the end of the day. I believe in this place, and I believe in how I feel about Malaysia and Malaysians, because this is a part of me, exactly what you said.
August 10, 2007 at 1:39 am
What would a person be without his ideals? In my opinion, hollow. While our ideals might be different, we should keep them – because (going back to the merdeka theme), we wouldn’t have been independent without idealists, we wouldn’t have peace without idealists, we wouldn’t have a great deal of the things that we have today if someone didn’t think that the world should be better than what it is today. Some of us were meant to sit back and reap the rewards and some of us were meant to do the work. So Meesh, GO GO GO! (I do mean go. U know where.)
August 23, 2007 at 8:31 pm
[...] I was tagged by a fellow blogger to contribute something to Nizam Bashir’s 50 posts to Merdeka. My post touched a few raw nerves. The mere mention that I was going to write for a website called [...]